The Hanging Garden
Canada, 1997, 91min
director: Thom Fitzgerald
cast: Kerry Fox, Seana McKenna, Christine Dunsworth
Ridiculed, beaten and forced to have heterosexual
Sex, a heavy boy returns home to his family after 10 years as a happy and
bodyconscious gay man
After
an absence of ten years, 25-year-old Sweet William returns to the family
for his sister Rosemary's wedding. Badly overweight, unhappy and physically
abused by father Whiskey Mac, he once ran away from home. Now Rosemary
is to marry, of all people, Sweet William's old friend Fletcher. Grandmother
Grace, now suffering from Alzheimer's Disease, once caught them during
a night-time exchange of intimacies and made sure Iris dragged her son
to the local prostitute Dusty Miller, who, for cash, is only too happy
to help desperate mothers with sons who don't conform to their expectations.
Now, out of reach of his family and weight problems, Sweet William has
a happy, openly gay relationship with his lover Dick. Despite being newly
wed, Fletcher finds it difficult not to show his feelings for the attractive
returnee. Against all expectations, Rosemary is not at all narrow-minded
about this, and even encourages her husband to continue where the two youths
left off, when they were rudely interrupted.
But there are other surprises in store for Sweet William, who now has
a younger brother – although, as it turns out, Violet is a girl. But that's
not all...
The family is as dysfunctional as ever, Whiskey Mac's alcoholism has
made some great advances, as has Grace's senility, Aunt Laura continuously
interrupts everybody and Rosemary earns a reputation as the most irritated
bride in cinematic history. Mother Iris has finally had enough, and is
considering drastic measures.
In the midst of all this there are still some skeletons to be found
in cupboards, so that the greatest stroke of fate in the family's history
so far can finally be dealt with...
Warning: A later storyline
is revealed in this review.
-
Screenplay writer and debut feature-film director Thom Fitzgerald
crosses the up till now carefully observed boundaries of cinematic possibilities.
Whilst in the last century, literature has gone on to new temporal and
unnatural planes, the cinema has basically followed the same conservative
structures year in, year out; either totally realistic, linear timelines,
or completely divorced from reality in the minds of the characters. Recently
magical realism has, happily, become more popular. While this does pep
up an otherwise naturalistic story with selected moments – still perfectly
logical – mostly near the end of a film, The Hanging Garden
is surreal to the core.
At the age of 15 the teased, beaten and sexually abused 160-kilo (350-pound)
gay boy could not face the world any more, and hanged himself on the apple
tree in the garden. Although he obviously did die, he managed to make a
life for himself in the city. For all concerned, death is robbed of its
finality, and nobody is particularly amazed at Sweet William's return.
Every morning, his own youthful body hangs from the tree, and is cut down
by his father, in tears. All just a dream, a ghost story? Certainly not,
and that's not important.
It is about holding out even the most difficult times, soon there will
be the opportunity to lead a more satisfying life. The grown-up, happy
protagonist is treated as an alternative to the void which normally follows
a suicide.
Another of the film's messages is that you always need your family,
even if they do get on your nerves. I would like to oppose the premise
that you should always fall back on your blood relatives; note the North
American familial sentimentality in films by gay directors. But why complain?
Compared to other homecoming films (Home for the Holidays,
Taylor's Return, The Myth of Fingerprints to
name the most successful), where the kids return to the family home for
Thanksgiving, The Hanging Garden is a supernova next to countless
servings of porridge: hard-nosed, rebellious and unashamedly magical. Yes!
ki, Milan – Berlin
translation: andrew
© Goldwyn Films / MGM Distribution
Co. / by C. Reardon
US: November 7th, 1997
UK: ?
France: ?
seen during the:
shown during the:
1998 Sundance Film Festival
27th International Film Festival Rotterdam 1998gelaufen
während des:
Deutsche Version
Filmdata:
Official link: None or not known.
copyright:
Queer View, January 9th 1998